Politics

Puerto Rico Supreme Court Chief Justice Defends Judicial Independence Amid LUMA Contract Dispute with Governor

Published Nov 11, 2026, 12:19 PM ASTvia El Nuevo Día

Also reported by Metro PR.

At a glance

  • Chief Justice Maite D. Oronoz Rodríguez said on Wednesday, November 11, that no one, whatever office they hold, can intervene in a judicial determination, reacting to reports Governor Jenniffer González Colón allegedly contacted Supreme Court justices about the LUMA Energy contract case.
  • La Fortaleza Public Affairs Secretary Jean Peña Payano "categorically" rejected the allegations, while LUMA president and CEO Janisse Quiñones demanded an "immediate investigation."

Why this matters: The dispute reaches the island’s highest court while the case to cancel LUMA Energy’s contract, which governs electricity for the whole island, is pending, putting the judiciary’s handling of that contract in the public eye.

Our coverage

Power live: 555 customers out island-wide at 2:14 AM

Maite D. Oronoz Rodríguez, chief justice of the Puerto Rico Supreme Court, defended the independence of the Judicial Branch on Wednesday and said no one, regardless of the office held, can interfere in court decisions. She was reacting to reports that Governor Jenniffer González Colón allegedly communicated directly with Supreme Court justices to influence the case filed to cancel the contract with the LUMA Energy consortium.

The robe does not respond to pressure or to particular interests.

Her statements followed a categorical rejection of the allegations by Jean Peña Payano, La Fortaleza’s secretary of public affairs, while LUMA president and chief executive Janisse Quiñones demanded an "immediate investigation." Oronoz Rodríguez said judicial independence is one of the fundamental pillars of the democratic system. She said it means judges resolve disputes with impartiality, in accordance with the law and the arguments presented to the court, free of pressure, political interests or outside influence.

She added that it is not only an institutional guarantee but also a fundamental guarantee for citizens, who have the right to have their disputes resolved under the law and not through arbitrary criteria, and that it is an individual and non-waivable responsibility of everyone who wears the robe. She said she trusts that the justices of the Supreme Court are and will continue to be faithful to that duty.

"The robe does not respond to pressure or to particular interests. It responds only to the Constitution, to the laws and to the obligation to dispense justice with absolute independence," she said.

In context

SourceEl Nuevo Día

Follow this story

Our coverage

Power live: 555 customers out island-wide at 2:14 AM

  1. · Metro PRLUMA CEO Demands Investigation of Claims of Pressure on Puerto Rico Supreme Court Justices
  2. · Microjuris al DíaGovernor Signs Judiciary Reform; Supreme Court Chief Justice Raises Constitutional Concerns
  3. · Microjuris al DíaSupreme Court Chief Justice Asks Governor to Veto Senate Bill 1096 Judicial Reform