The University of Puerto Rico (UPR) Law Review is developing a policy on the use of artificial intelligence to guide authors and editors as these tools enter legal research and writing, its Editorial Board said. The initiative is being developed as part of the work of the Special Projects Committee of Volume 96 and seeks criteria for the use of these tools at the different stages of the editorial process.
Emmanuel Rentas Báez said artificial intelligence tools are part of legal research and writing, and that the review has committed to evaluating each submitted piece "with greater rigor and thoroughness." The review is conducting a comparative study of policies adopted by law schools and academic law journals in other jurisdictions, aiming for a policy that fits the publication’s functions and harmonizes authors’ work with editorial evaluation.
The review has not formally established which uses of artificial intelligence it will consider acceptable; pending issues include its use to organize ideas, improve writing, research or generate parts of legal analysis. Joseph Machado Vélez and Delvin Caraballo Rodríguez said the tools require more attention when evaluating submissions, though the review maintains its verification standards.
They said a main challenge is not only setting general prohibitions but offering clear criteria applicable to each stage, and that the rules must respond to new scenarios as the technology evolves. Machado Vélez said artificial intelligence should be understood as a support tool, not a substitute for critical thinking, legal analysis or the author’s own voice, and that no tool can exempt an author from answering for each claim, citation and argument.
He urged those submitting articles to verify citations and legislative, case-law and doctrinal references directly in primary sources, ensure the analysis reflects the author’s judgment and be transparent about artificial intelligence use.