Community

Tourist Sues LUMA and San Juan Over Open Manhole Fall in Santurce

Published Nov 20, 2026, 8:50 AM ASTvia NotiCel

At a glance

  • The federal suit, filed November 18, names LUMA Energy, the Municipality of San Juan, LUMA Energy ServCo and Óptima Seguros, the Municipality’s insurer.
  • Joyce, who fell into a manhole up to four feet deep on Iturriaga street on the night of February 21, needed about 62 stitches and spent nearly 15 hours in the emergency room.
  • The complaint seeks more than $350,000 in damages and more than $10,000 in medical costs, and asks for double compensation if grave disregard for safety is found.

Why this matters: The suit targets the same street lighting and municipal infrastructure Santurce residents and businesses around the Placita live with daily, and a ruling on who must keep manholes covered and lit could set precedent for how quickly both parties fix hazards.

Our coverage

Power live: 7,388 customers out island-wide at 9:46 AM

A tourist from Massachusetts, John Joyce, sued LUMA Energy and the Municipality of San Juan after falling into an uncovered manhole while walking with his partner near the Placita de Santurce, in San Juan, Puerto Rico. The complaint was filed on November 18 in the Federal Court for the District of Puerto Rico. According to the filing, on the night of February 21 Joyce was walking hand in hand with his partner along Iturriaga street when he fell into a manhole between three and a half and four feet deep, partly filled with water.

He sank to his armpits and suffered a deep laceration to his left leg. An ambulance took him to the Doctors’ Center hospital in San Juan, where he received about 62 stitches and spent nearly 15 hours in the emergency room. Days later the wound became infected.

The suit alleges Joyce was left with permanent damage and a large scar, and that his vacation in Puerto Rico was ruined. It claims the Municipality failed to cover the manhole, creating a hazard for pedestrians, and accuses LUMA of negligence for not maintaining lighting in the area, which prevented the hole from being seen.

The suit seeks more than $350,000 for damages and more than $10,000 for medical expenses, and asks that compensation be doubled if a jury finds grave disregard for safety. It also names LUMA Energy ServCo, Óptima Seguros as the Municipality’s insurer, and unidentified companies that may have infrastructure beneath the manhole.

In context (787daily, from public data)

  • LUMA's portal showed 0.2% of customers out at 6:05 AM AST on Nov 22, 2026. Across the 77 days 787daily has tracked it, the daily average is 0.3% and the worst was 3.5% on Nov 14, 2026.

    LUMA Energy outage portal · Nov 22, 6:05 AM AST
  • Customers in LUMA's San Juan region averaged 29.2 hours without power in the fiscal year that ended in June 2026, against 27.6 hours island-wide.

    LUMA operates the transmission and distribution system. A LUMA region is a utility district named for its hub town, not that town alone.

    PR Energy Bureau, as filed by LUMA · fiscal year ending June 2026
  • San Juan

    336,160Census estimate, 2020–20241521Founded47.9 sq mi (124 km²)Area
SourceNotiCel

Our coverage

Power live: 7,388 customers out island-wide at 9:46 AM