Community / Crime & Safety

Lawyer Questions Value of New Statement in Elvia Cabrera Case

Published Oct 14, 2026, 7:57 AM ASTvia Radio Isla

Also reported by El Nuevo Día.

At a glance

  • The defense of Anthonieska Avilés presented a new sworn statement claiming Elvia Cabrera did not provide the sharp object used to kill Gabriela Nicole
  • The Department of Justice stated that the new evidence was already available during the trial
  • The Justice Department is prepared to respond to any new trial or appeal request from Cabrera’s defense

Why this matters: The case has significant implications for the family of Gabriela Nicole and the community in Aibonito, where the murder took place, as they seek justice and closure.

In Puerto Rico, lawyer Chatal Delgado has expressed skepticism about a new sworn statement presented by the defense of Anthonieska Avilés, claiming her mother, Elvia Cabrera, did not provide the sharp object used to kill Gabriela Nicole in Aibonito. Delgado stated that the defense faces a significant challenge in proving the veracity of the new information, including when it was discovered, why it was not available earlier, and its reliability.

The Department of Justice said it is prepared to respond to any new trial or appeal request from Cabrera’s defense, citing solid evidence of her guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The Justice Department also stated that the new evidence claimed by the defense was already available during the trial. Delgado believes the new statement may be intended to influence public perception of Cabrera’s involvement in the murder.

The case is ongoing, with the Justice Department confident in its ability to defend its position and secure justice for Gabriela Nicole and her family.

In context — 787daily, from public data

SourceRadio Isla

More in Community