Community

San Juan Court Hears Eviction Case Against Estate of Félix Plaud de Choudens

Published Nov 16, 2026, 4:21 PM ASTvia El Nuevo Día

At a glance

  • Judge Cecilia Suau Badía reserved judgment in the eviction case and will issue a written ruling within 10 days
  • Homeowner Diana Ortiz Torres testified that rent defaults on the Sagrado Corazón house began in 2020 and that in 2026 only a May payment was made
  • Francisco Olmos, who lives in the property, said he pays $1,000 in rent and could not show proof of payment because he lost the contract in a flood

A San Juan court on Monday, November 16, heard an eviction lawsuit that homeowner Diana Ortiz Torres filed posthumously against Félix Plaud de Choudens, his mother Estrella de Choudens Colón and Francisco Olmos, who currently lives in the house in the Sagrado Corazón neighborhood of San Juan. Judge Cecilia Suau Badía, of courtroom 908 at the San Juan Court, reserved judgment and said she will issue a written ruling within 10 days.

Testifying under oath, Ortiz Torres said that in December 2025 Plaud de Choudens asked for time to avoid the eviction suit over unpaid rent so that "some boys from the social services department" living there would not be left on the street. She said rent defaults began in 2020, when the lease with option to buy was signed, and that in 2026 he made only one payment, in May.

Olmos said he has lived there since 2024 under a sublease paying $1,000 in rent to Plaud de Choudens, the same amount Plaud de Choudens owed Ortiz Torres, but could not produce proof of payment, saying he lost the contract in a flood. He appeared without a lawyer, said he did not understand the process and had failed to get help from Servicios Legales de Puerto Rico; the judge said he had been given time to hire counsel and that summary evictions cannot keep being delayed.

Olmos said he was with Plaud de Choudens in Guayama on October 22 when he got out of the car and never returned, and that he reported him missing at a Guayama police station on October 23 before finding the body that afternoon. Plaud de Choudens, known for pro-statehood activism since his university years, was killed on October 22 and found the next day in a vacant lot in Guayama; authorities presume William Noel Rivera Sánchez, a former business partner with whom he had financial disputes, killed him, and Rivera Sánchez was found dead on October 23 after posting videos confessing the killings of Plaud de Choudens and lawyer Luis Quiñones González.

Olmos said he has not been able to work since. De Choudens Colón did not testify because she is outside Puerto Rico and reportedly "fears for her life." The Department of the Family and the Mental Health and Addiction Services Administration (ASSMCA) said separately that the property does not appear in their records as a licensed home.

In context (787daily, from public data)

SourceEl Nuevo Día

Follow this story

  1. · WAPA TVLawsuit Against Félix Plaud Exposes Disputes Over Residence Under ASSMCA Investigation
  2. · NotiUnoDávila Colón: Social Media Comments Glorifying Félix Plaud Killings Reflect 'rottenness of the soul' of Some Puerto Ricans
  3. · El Nuevo DíaWeeks Before the Killings, William Rivera Asked a Court to Order Félix Plaud to Pay $13,500
Full timeline